Showing posts with label Dick Francis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dick Francis. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 18, 2022

Mini Reviews - XIII

 The Ghost of Blackwood Hall (Nancy Drew #25)
  - Carolyn Keene

1/5 stars

Picked this up on a whim from the book sale I went to, for two reasons - I haven't read a Nancy Drew book in perhaps three decades, and this original Armada publication copy was in quite a decent condition (I also hit a jackpot with a very good Three Investigators - The Vanishing Treasure, one of my favorites in the series).

So, I was reminded why I never liked Nancy Drew, even when I was in middle school and loved Three Investigators Series. First the plot that is completely illogical - grown women putting money in tree trunks to supposedly support an orphanage, people believing in seances and spirits telling them exact details of places to bury wealth and names of people to avoid. Then, the plot hole - how did the thieves know their victim's jewellery so well that they were able to create such great imitations upfront? Next - sleuthing - consisting of officials giving all information that a 18 year old asks for, lawyer father getting information for her, and her being rescued from difficult situations by father or boyfriend.

I don't think I felt this in my younger days, but now I felt that the writing was juvenile, and I am inclined to put it at the level of Enid Blyton's detective series for younger children.



The Golden Keel
  - Desmond Bagley

3.5/5 stars

Desmond Bagley is one of my favorite thriller writers, the old-school straightforward action/spy thrillers being the kind I like. I also feel a partiality towards treasure hunt/chase stories, so it was no surprise that I enjoyed this one that tells a tale of Nazi gold lost during WW2.
I did expect the 'twist' that came towards the end, as well as the final outcome, yet the pace and the narration kept me engaged. The build-up of the story and the execution was done well enough. I wouldn't call it a must-read for the genre, but its quite a nice one to keep one interested to see how it unfolds.



High Stakes
  - Dick Francis

3.5/5 stars

Like most of the other novels by Dick Francis, High Stakes is also a thriller set in the world of horse racing. It does involve a bit of the how the betting works, but I am glad it did not delved into much detail of jockeying or care of horses - one of his previous books I read went into these aspects too deep and bored with these, I skipped whole paragraphs to get to the main story.
The rich protagonist, Scott, gets interested in buying racehorses, even though he knows very little about racing and nothing about horses. The book opens to his realization that his trainer and adviser Leeds has been swindling him outrageously, playing on his generosity as well as lack of knowledge. From there starts a cat-and-mouse game, with Scott playing to safeguard his property and reputation, and Leeds, his ill-gotten gains and freedom.
It is a well written book, with a likeable protagonist you can sympathize with and an exciting sequence of events as he plans to protect his interests where he cannot expect to get help from the law.


Tuesday, October 29, 2019

Longshot

LongshotLongshot
  - Dick Francis

My rating: 3 of 5 stars

My favorite genre, after I graduated from children's books to those for adults, used to be mystery/thriller. I loved Sherlock Holmes and Perry Mason series, and books by Alistair Maclean and Desmond Bagley. However, in last few years, I have been having trouble finding the kind of thrillers I like; most of contemporary works being psychological thrillers, frequently with gruesome details, psychopaths, and child abuse. That's when someone recommended me Dick Francis (though I no longer remember who or when), and I added Longshot and Danger to my reading list.

Over the Diwali weekend, I wanted to relax with something engaging but unstressful, so I picked up Longshot for a quick read. It turned out to be fairly entertaining but unremarkable book. The protagonist, John Kendall, a budding author of fiction, is an expert on surviving in extreme conditions. Brief descriptions of these skills are sprinkled throughout the book; they are interesting, and also come in handy in the course of the events in the novel. He accepts a commission from well known horse trainer Tremayne, and comes to stay at his family home. Over time, he comes to realize the warm and compassionate nature of his employer, beneath the autocratic and sometimes unreasonable exterior. It makes for nice reading, though it is a well used trope. Kendall's interaction with Tremayne's teenage son Gareth was the best part of the book, as Gareth comes to look up to him as a mentor/elder brother.

Since the employer and the second main character Tremayne is a trainer of racing horses, there is a lot of detail about horse racing in the book (and is a consistent theme in his works, as I come to know from other reviews). Initially I read about those, but after a while I lost interest and skipped the details that didn't have a bearing on the plot.

In these kind of novels, the protagonist usually has some extraordinary skills, which gradually emerge to save others from peril. I think this one went a bit too far on this aspect - Kendall's survival skills, and keen observation and reasoning were alright (and expected), but his learning to ride racehorses well enough to become an amateur jockey in less than two weeks was rather far fetched.
Coming to the question of the genre, which is the main point, I wouldn't call it a thriller. It is a murder mystery alright, but I don't think it is a great one. The murder comes into picture after quite a bit. The identity of the murderer involved an obvious red herring, and another usual device - it turns out to be a very unlikely character. In the good ones, the path to discovery is where the tension lies, but I didn't find it to be one of those biting-your-nails kind of journey.

My rating: 2.5 stars, rounded to 3.